How to Choose Between Two Good Options
To choose between two good options, compare downsides instead of upsides, notice which future you already picture yourself in, favor the option that closes fewer doors, ask which path you'd wonder about later, and flip a coin to see how you feel about the result.
- Pick the downside you could live with.
- Notice which option you already imagine living.
- Favor the option that keeps more doors open.
- Ask which path you'd wonder about later.
- Flip a coin and watch your reaction.
When two options are both good, a pro-and-con list stops separating them, so tiebreakers help: which downside you could accept, which option keeps more choices open, and which path you would wonder about later. Research supports a little boldness in close calls. In Steven Levitt's coin-toss study, published in the Review of Economic Studies, people who made a major change they were unsure about reported being happier six months later than those who stayed put.
The job in one city pays better; the job in the other is where you want to live. Both lists are the same length. The decision isn't hard because the options are bad. It's hard because they're both good.
How do you decide when both options are good?
When both options are good, the better question isn't 'which has more upside' — it's 'which downside is more acceptable.' Imagine each option going badly. Not catastrophically — just disappointingly. Which version of disappointed are you more okay being? The one whose worst case you can absorb is often the safer pick. In close decisions it is easy to focus on upside and skip the question of which downside you could actually live with.
Does imagining yourself in each option help you decide?
Without trying to decide, picture yourself a year into option A. Then a year into option B. One of them usually feels more vivid, more textured, more like a real life — and the other feels more like a hypothetical. The vividness asymmetry is data. It doesn't mean you'll be happier with the vivid option; it means part of you is already there, and that part has been quietly leaning. The leaning is information the analytical comparison can't generate.
Should you pick the option that keeps more doors open?
Some good options keep more doors open than others. Taking a job locks you out of competing offers; declining one keeps the search alive but loses that specific opportunity. When two options are close, the one that preserves more choices is worth extra weight, because you'll learn more in the meantime that helps the next decision. A decision you can reverse costs less to get wrong.
Which choice will you regret more?
Predicting which option will make you happier is hard; predicting which one you'd wonder about is often easier. Five years from now, which path-not-taken would nag you? Research by Thomas Gilovich and Victoria Medvec found that, looking back over years, people regret things they didn't do more often than things they did. That makes the unchosen path worth a serious look.
Does flipping a coin help you make a decision?
When the analytical work has run its course, flip an actual coin. Don't act on the result. Watch what you feel when it lands. If the coin says A and you feel relieved, you wanted A. If it says A and you feel disappointed, you wanted B. The reaction is the data; the coin's only job was to surface it. This isn't superstition; it's a way of forcing the gut to declare itself when the analytical brain refuses to. Use the coin to find out what you already knew.
Sources
Get the tiebreaker that actually breaks the tie
Decision Coach takes both options, applies your specific constraints and preferences, runs reversibility and regret analysis, and returns a single answer — not 'consider these factors' but a real choice you can act on.
Found this useful? Link to it.
https://deftbrain.com/guides/decisions/how-to-choose-between-two-good-options
Free to read, no account, no paywall — link away.