How to steelman an argument you disagree with

To steelman an argument you disagree with, find how its most thoughtful supporters explain it, identify the value it protects, state it aloud in their terms without hedging, admit the part you can't easily refute, and then respond to that strongest version rather than a weak one.

  1. Learn the argument from people who hold it.
  2. Name the value underneath it.
  3. State it in their words, without hedges.
  4. Find the part you can't easily refute.
  5. Argue against the best version, not the worst.

Updated October 9, 2026 · By the DeftBrain team

Steelmanning means building the strongest, most charitable version of a position you disagree with before responding to it, the opposite of a straw man. In practice, that involves learning the argument from its most thoughtful advocates, identifying the value it is protecting (such as liberty, safety or fairness), stating it in terms its supporters would accept, and acknowledging any part you find hard to answer. Responding to that version makes your disagreement more honest and more persuasive.

You're demolishing the other side's argument and starting to wonder why anyone believes it. That feeling is usually a sign you're arguing with the easiest version of their case, not the one its smartest supporters hold.

How to do it
1

How do you find the strongest version of an argument?

Do not Google "arguments against X" and skim the takedowns. Find the people who hold the position you disagree with, and read or listen to them telling other people who agree with them why they hold it. The internal version of an argument is usually more sophisticated than the version that gets aimed outward. If you cannot summarize their case in a way that they would nod at and say "yes, that is what I actually think," you have not steelmanned it yet — you have steelmanned a costume of it.

2

What is the value behind an opposing view?

Many disagreements are not actually about the surface claim. They are about which value gets weighted higher when values conflict. Liberty vs. safety. Tradition vs. progress. Group cohesion vs. individual autonomy. If you can name the value that their position is protecting, you stop arguing past each other. You also realize that you probably hold that value too, just at a different weight, which is a much more honest starting point for actually changing anyone's mind, including your own.

3

How do you state someone else's argument fairly?

No "I guess they would say." No "the most charitable reading might be." Just say their position the way they would say it, with their conviction, in language they would use. If saying it makes you uncomfortable, that is the right discomfort. You are practicing inhabiting a view you do not hold, which is the only way to know whether you actually disagree with it or whether you have been disagreeing with a cartoon of it.

4

What should you do with the part of their argument you can't refute?

Inside every steelman there will be one piece that is genuinely hard to argue against. Find it. Do not dismiss it. Do not flip back to the easy parts. The strongest version of any opposing position contains at least one true thing. The discipline is to admit which true thing it is — even just to yourself — before you go back to defending your own view. It is a step people often skip, which is one reason so many disagreements never move.

5

How do you disagree after steelmanning someone's argument?

When it is your turn to push back, push back on the steelman, not on the version they would never claim. "I hear that the strongest case for this is X, and the part I find hardest to refute is Y. Where I still land differently is..." This is the move that changes minds, including the minds of people watching the conversation. Refuting the worst version of someone makes you feel right. Refuting the best version of them makes you persuasive.

Try it now — free

Face the strongest version of the other side, before you have to face the real one.

Argue Smarter is the intellectual sparring partner that will not let you off easy. State your position and get hit with the steelman — not a caricature, but what a thoughtful, well-informed person who genuinely disagrees would actually say. Switch sides mid-debate to argue the other case yourself, or concede strategically when a point lands.

A real steelman of any position you state — never a strawman Switch sides mid-debate and argue the other case yourself Five debate formats including Socratic, Lincoln-Douglas, and Oxford Source check any claim while you argue — yours or theirs Strategic concession — practice acknowledging points that land
Open Argue Smarter → No account required to get started.

Found this useful? Link to it.

https://deftbrain.com/guides/conversations/how-to-steelman-an-argument-you-disagree-with

Free to read, no account, no paywall — link away.

Related situations

💡 Missing something?

Didn’t find what you need? Suggest a tool. We read every suggestion, and the best become new tools.

📮 Newsletter

One useful tool a month — the one worth knowing about before life demands it.