How to Write a Recommendation Letter (For a Coworker)
To write a recommendation letter for a coworker, open with how you worked alongside them, describe what you saw up close in collaboration, compare them with peers rather than reports, say plainly what you can't speak to, and end with a specific endorsement such as wanting them on your team.
- Describe the working relationship honestly.
- Focus on what you saw them do up close.
- Compare them with peers at their level.
- Say what you can't speak to.
- Close with a specific endorsement.
A recommendation letter from a coworker, rather than a manager, is most credible when it reflects a peer's view. That means stating how and for how long you worked together, describing specific behaviors you observed directly (how they collaborate, handle disagreement or help when someone is stuck), comparing them with colleagues at a similar level, noting what you can't assess, and ending with a concrete endorsement, such as saying you'd want them on your next team.
A coworker asked for a letter, and the usual format assumes you were their boss. You weren't, and you don't want to overstate things. Peer letters have their own strengths.
How do you start a recommendation letter for a coworker?
Don't try to sound like a manager — you weren't one. Open with the actual relationship: "I worked alongside David on the [team/project] for two years as a fellow [role]." The reader will read peer-to-peer recommendations differently than supervisor recommendations, and that's fine. Your perspective has its own value: you saw them in collaboration, not in evaluation, and that view is sometimes more useful for the role they're applying to.
What should you include in a peer recommendation letter?
As a coworker, you have access to behaviors that managers don't see — how they handle disagreement with peers, how they help when someone's stuck, how they communicate in real time on the messy parts of work. Pick the things you actually observed at this resolution. "When the data pipeline broke, he was the one who'd stay late to dig in" or "In our standup, she always asked the question nobody else wanted to ask." These details are credible from a peer in a way they wouldn't be from a manager looking down.
How do you compare a coworker to others in a letter?
If you're going to calibrate, calibrate against people at their level. "Among the engineers I've worked with at [Company] in the last five years, she's one I'd most want on my team." Not "top performer" — that's manager-language, and you can't credibly say it. Peer-comparison framing lands honestly: you're saying who you'd want to work with again, not who you'd hire. The reader can use both kinds of information; they just need to know which they're getting.
What if you can't speak to some of their skills?
There are things you can't speak to as a coworker — their leadership ability if they weren't leading, their judgment under pressure if you didn't see it, their growth over time if you only worked together briefly. Don't fake those. "I didn't manage David, so I can't speak directly to how he handles direct reports, but in our peer collaboration he was consistently the one who..." Acknowledging the limits of your view makes everything else you say more credible. Letters that overreach lose authority; letters that stay in their lane gain it.
How should you end a recommendation letter for a coworker?
End with what you'd specifically endorse them for. "I'd hire him onto a team I was leading, and I'd actively look for him at any future company I joined." "If I had a peer slot to fill, she'd be the first call." Specifics from a coworker are more valuable than vague enthusiasm because the reader knows the source has skin in the game — you're vouching for a future working relationship, not just a past one. That's what makes a peer recommendation hit.
A coworker letter that actually helps them
Ghost Writer takes the projects you worked on together, what you saw them do, and the role they're applying for and produces a peer-perspective letter that lands with credibility.
Found this useful? Link to it.
https://deftbrain.com/guides/conversations/how-to-write-a-recommendation-letter-for-a-coworker
Free to read, no account, no paywall — link away.