How to Write a Recommendation Letter
A strong recommendation letter says how you know the person and for how long, gives a clear overall judgment early, tells one specific story that shows their qualities, compares them honestly with a real peer group, and briefly addresses any obvious question a reader might have.
- Open with your relationship and its length.
- State your headline judgment early.
- Tell one specific anecdote.
- Compare them with a real reference group.
- Address an obvious question briefly.
A recommendation letter for a job, graduate program or scholarship is most useful to the reader when it establishes the writer's standing (relationship and duration), states a clear judgment near the top, supports it with a concrete example rather than a list of adjectives, and places the candidate within an honest comparison group, such as 'one of the strongest analysts I've managed'. Briefly addressing a likely concern, like a short track record, makes the rest more credible.
You agreed because they're good. Now the only sentences coming are the ones every letter has: 'I am pleased to recommend…', 'a hard worker who…'. They're correct and they tell the reader nothing.
How do you start a recommendation letter?
First sentence, two facts: your relationship and the duration. "I supervised Maria for three years as her direct manager at [Company]." That's it. The reader needs to know whether your endorsement is from a position of real knowledge or distant acquaintance, and you need to establish credibility before opinion. Many recommendation letters skip this and open with praise; the praise lands harder when the reader knows the source's standing first.
Where should your main recommendation go in the letter?
Don't bury the verdict. "She is among the strongest [analysts/students/engineers] I have worked with in my [N years] in this role." The reader is going to scan this letter — admissions officers and hiring managers read many of them. Give them the takeaway in the first paragraph. Vague openers make the reader work to find your actual opinion; clear ones tell them what you think and give them context for the rest of the letter.
What example should you include in a recommendation letter?
Adjectives don't work. "Hardworking, intelligent, kind" reads identically to every other letter the reader has seen. One specific story does more work than a paragraph of adjectives: "When the analytics platform went down before the board meeting, she rebuilt the key dashboards from scratch in four hours and presented them as if she'd been planning to all along." The story shows the qualities; you don't have to name them. Pick the one anecdote that captures who they are and write it concretely.
Should you compare the candidate to others in a recommendation letter?
Recommendations land harder when they're explicitly comparative. "In the last decade, I have managed approximately 30 [analysts]. She is one of the top three." "Of the students I have taught in my graduate seminar, hers was the second-best thesis." The reader has no way to interpret "excellent" without a reference frame; comparisons give them one. Be honest about the frame — top three out of how many, of what kind. This is one of the biggest differences between letters that read as supportive and letters that read as decisive.
Should a recommendation letter mention weaknesses?
If there's something a reader might wonder about — a gap, a weakness, a transition — name it and address it. "While she is earlier in her career than typical applicants, her trajectory in the last 18 months suggests..." "She does not yet have publication history, but the work in her current draft is ready." Letters that engage one honest question come across as credible. Letters that ignore obvious questions come across as sales pitches. The acknowledgment is what makes the rest of the letter trustworthy.
Turn rough notes into a polished letter in minutes
Ghost Writer takes your bullet points, your relationship, and the role they're applying for and writes a structured letter — opener, headline, anecdote, comparison, counter-question — in your voice.
Found this useful? Link to it.
https://deftbrain.com/guides/conversations/how-to-write-a-recommendation-letter
Free to read, no account, no paywall — link away.